Critically Important Pur Water Filter Pitcher Pros and Cons

Pur Water Filter Pitcher Cons

Red CrossVery slow fill time.

The filter takes a long time, sometimes up to one full hour.

Red CrossThe LED might not work.

This model is based on an LED light that notifies you when the filter needs to be changed. However, some customers complain that the LED does not work with their device.

Red CrossNot effective at treating limescale.

The ion exchange filter used to soften the water could be better. Although water is noticeably softer after being filtered with Pur, it still leaves limescale deposits. This is no use to you if have limescale issues in your home.

Pur Water Filter Pitcher Pros

Green Plus Arrow

By far the biggest benefits of using a Pur water filter is that it can filter heavy duty contaminants like mercury and trace pharmaceuticals.

Green Plus Arrow

This filter is better than most of the other basic pitcher jugs like Brita at removing these substances. Therefore, it is the safe option if you have worrying contaminants in your water.

Green Plus Arrow

BPA-free plastic. BPA is a real concern when using plastics in a product that is linked to a consumable like water. The manufacturer’s certify that all components of the Pur pitcher that come into contact with water are made of BPA-free plastic. This is an advantage because you can use the filter for a long time without harmful plastics getting into your drinking water.

Green Plus Arrow

Efficient filtration. Although this water filter does not work fast, it can deliver high quality water. Most impurities in the water are removed before it enters your glass.

PUR Classic 18-Cup Dispenser

The PUR classic is larger than the average water filter pitcher and great for people that have a big family.

It’s based on MAXION® filter technologies.

These filter technologies can eliminate 95% of certain industrial pollutants, 96% of mercury and 94% of some pharmaceuticals.

  • The result of this is that it can reduce chlorine for better tasting water.
  • It’s slim design optimizes the space so it can fit in the refrigerator shelf.
  • All PUR Launcher filters fit into all PUR launcher / dispensers so it’s easy to find and replace filter cartridges.
  • Has a very large capacity that can hold 1125 gallons of water over the life time of the average cartridge.
  • BPA – free.
Dimensions: 5.63 W x 15.75H x 10.25L

PUR Classic 11-Cup Pitcher with LED

Certified to reduce 2x more contaminants than Brita.

  • MAXION® filtration can remove 95% of certain industrial pollutants, 96% of mercury, and 94% of trace drugs.
  • Reduces chlorine (taste and odor).
  • Easy-fill lid, which can be activated with your thumb.
  • Built-in LED filter life indicator.
  • The package available on Amazon includes a free filter cartridge.
  • Filters 40 gallons or up to two months.
  • BPA Free
Dimensions: 10.62W x 11.25H x 6.62 L

PUR Basic 7-Cup Pitcher

Certified to reduce 2x more contaminants than Brita. This is a smaller pitcher of all the Pur pitchers reviewed in this article.

The smaller size also means that price is also slightly lower than the others.

Its size makes it the ideal option for people who live alone, don’t have a lot of space. Despite this, the filtration abilities are similar to the others.

Comes with MAXION® filters that deal with mercury (96%), pharmaceuticals (94%) and industrial pollutants (95%).

Easy to fill with a thumb-activated design.

Buying it from Amazon means you can get a filter cartridge included (be sure to select the right option).

Can reduce things like chlorine.

Filters work for 40 gallons of water meaning they can last up to 2 months.

Certified BPA-free.

Dimensions: 10.90 W x 11.30H x 4.80L

Why Pur Might NOT Be WORTH it

Red CrossIts filters have a low capacity. For instance, the 7-cup pitcher only has a 40 gallon capacity.

Red CrossThis is not the biggest filter capacity so may mean that you need to change filters more often than other models. This is not ideal for some people, even if the filter change does not take long.AquaTru

Red CrossWhen your filter only has a 40 gallon capacity this means more cartridge filter changes. This can mean necessary filter replacements every 4 to 6 weeks. Of course this depends on your water usage.

Red CrossThis is on top of the previously mention issues of it being slow to filter, LED light issues and might not effectively deal with limescale.

Is Pur Water Filter Pitcher WORTH It?


In comparison to Brita, the Pur water filter pitcher wins hands down.

Mr Water Geek ThinkingAnd yes, this is one of the best pitchers with water filters on the market today because it deals with tough contaminants like mercury.

However, if you have serious water pollution concerns there are much better alternatives on the market.

For instance, there is the Aquasana machine for clean water. The Aquasana Clean Water Machine has a longer filter capacity so better value for money.mrwatergeek winner badge

This is a much larger generous capacity as it’s a 16-cup dispenser. It delivers filtered water at the touch of a button.

The thin decanter with 8 cups fits easily into the door of your refrigerator.AquaTru

It’s filter is based on activated carbon. This gives it the capacity to reduce everything from pesticides, pharmaceutical products, VOCs (Volatile Organic Compounds), herbicides and MTBE (Methyl tertiary butyl ether).

It then also filters the water through a carbon catalyst to remove chlorine and chloroamines.

The absolute mechanical filter is also capable of filtrating through submicrons. This is effective against cysts that can sometimes be resistant to asbestos, chlorine, giardia and cryptosporidium.Check Prices & Read Customer Reviews

Finally there is an additional layer of heavy metal ion exchange that filters such as mercury and lead.

AquaTru Water Filter

Berkey Water Filter

AquaTruProPur Berkey Looking Water Filter System
- Arsenic: Approx 90% (unspecified).
- Fluoride by 91.8% (WITHOUT extra filters).
- Lead 97.5%
- Benzene 99.9%
- Chlorine 96.6%
- Cysts 99.99%
- Arsenic by 99.9% (special filters required).
- Fluoride by 99.9% (special filters required).
- Lead 97.5%
- Benzene 99.8%
Available in 1-size only. Available in various sizes.
Plastic materials.Metal & plastic materials.
Number of filters: 3Number of filters: 2 - 4
Filter methods: Mechanical, Reverse Osmosis & Activated Carbon filters.Filter methods: Black microporous-filters & white fluoride Filters
4-stage filter process.2-stage filter process.
Holds a maximum water capacity of 3-quarts.2.25 Gallons
45.7 x 45.7 x 38.1 cm 19" High x 8.5" Diameter
System: 1 year limited warranty.Filters: 2 years; System: 1 year.
Full Performance Data Sheet (AquaTru).Berkey Contaminants List
NSF/ANSI test results
Yes, use code MRWATERGEEK
AquaTrue Coupon
Yes, Big Berkey bundle sale
mrwatergeek winner badge
mrwatergeek winner badgemrwatergeek winner badge

Similar Posts


  1. For the last week, there is always some water left unfiltered at the top of the pitcher cup no matter how long we wait.We only fill it to the Pur line twice, not all the way. either.

  2. How much does hot water that accidentally ran through a Pur faucet filter affect filtering ability?

  3. The PUR filtration system is making my dog and cats sick. They are all indoors. I have changed only to a PUR filter system. Yet they are getting sick from this change. I need answers. I have taken all the SO-CALLED PUR water away from them . I noticed they are not drinking this as they were without this filtering. Worried!!!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *