The Pros and Cons of Gravity Water Filters
Pros and Cons of Gravity Water Filters
Here is a list of the biggest advantages and disadvantages of gravity water filters.
Cons
You might sometimes find that there are parts that can be expensive to replace. So make sure you always handle the unit with care.
Getting a very cheap gravity water filter may mean that the filter cartridge is expensive to replace. This is very similar to how printer manufacturers make their money on cheap printers. Pro tip: always check the costs of replacing the cartridge before you buy.
Check how fast it can filter before you buy because some gravity water filters can take a very long time.
Pros
The gravity filtration process is usually very simple and efficient without making too much noise (if any).
There are so many different sizes, shapes and function levels to choose from.
You can put them almost anywhere in the home because they typically don’t need any electricity to operate.
Very low rate of mechanical issues with almost no need for on-going maintenance. Just make sure you replace the filter cartridge and operate the machine in accordance with the manufacturers’ instruction.
Doesn’t usually need electricity and this can save you a lot of money on electricity bills especially when compared to other filter methods.
Works on a very easy to understand technology, which means you can even build one your self as a DIY water filter if you don’t want to buy a commercially-made unit.
What To Consider Before Buying A Gravity Water Filter
Here is a quick buying guide for gravity water filters. The list below are some of the things you should review and take into consideration before you buy one:
Do you have enough space?
Gravity fed water filters come in many different shapes and sizes but you need to know where you’re going to put it and if you have enough space for your chosen device.
Can it filter enough water for you everyday?
To answer this question you need to know how much water you generally consume. Once you know this number, work out how much water filtration you get with each filter cartridge. This will let you know how often you need to replace cartridges and if your chosen filter can cope with your demands.
What do you need it to filter?
Find out what is in your water supply and you can do this by looking at the water quality report by looking at the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) dedicated agency in your state. Alternatively, you can get a water test kit and see what is in your water. Once you know what you need to filter then you just need to make sure the gravity filter you want to buy is able to cope with everything you find. Knowing exactly what contaminants are in your water will better help you to know which type of counter-top gravity filter system to get.
Alkaline or acidic water?
Another thing to check is the pH level of your water. A neutral number is 7 on the pH scale and any number that is lower than a 7 means you have acidic and higher numbers mean alkaline. Regularly drinking higher alkaline water has some health benefits. And if you want to enjoy some of these benefits then consider getting a gravity water filter that can improve the pH level.
AquaTru Water Filter | Berkey Water Filter |
- Arsenic: Approx 90% (unspecified). - Fluoride by 91.8% (WITHOUT extra filters). - Lead 97.5% - Benzene 99.9% - Chlorine 96.6% - Cysts 99.99% | - Arsenic by 99.9% (special filters required). - Fluoride by 99.9% (special filters required). - Lead 97.5% - Benzene 99.8% |
Available in 1-size only. | Available in various sizes. |
Plastic materials. | Metal & plastic materials. |
Number of filters: 3 | Number of filters: 2 - 4 |
Filter methods: Mechanical, Reverse Osmosis & Activated Carbon filters. | Filter methods: Black microporous-filters & white fluoride Filters |
4-stage filter process. | 2-stage filter process. |
Holds a maximum water capacity of 3-quarts. | 2.25 Gallons |
45.7 x 45.7 x 38.1 cm | 19" High x 8.5" Diameter |
System: 1 year limited warranty. | Filters: 2 years; System: 1 year. |
Full Performance Data Sheet (AquaTru). | Berkey Contaminants List NSF/ANSI test results |
SPECIAL OFFER? Yes, use code MRWATERGEEK | SPECIAL OFFER? Yes, Big Berkey bundle sale |
How Do Gravity Water Filter Systems Work?
Gravity water filters typically tend to work as a free standing unit, you put water in the top and then let gravity work its magic.
However, if you want to know how gravity filters work in more specific detail then consider that they work in two stages.
A gravity filter works with two containers. The top container is where the unfiltered water goes and it filters its way down to the bottom container were the filtration happens.
If the gravity filter works with activated charcoal then it will very likely include a microporous ceramic cartridge in the filter unit.
A charcoal gravity filter is very effective at removing things like bacteria, contaminants, chemicals and parasites from your water. This is important because parasites are capable of causing things like dysentery, typhoid and cholera.
Activated charcoal gravity water filters are also very good at removing things like chemicals.
Especially the types of chemicals that are common in tap water like chlorine, fluoride as well as heavy metals like copper, mercury and lead.
Gravity Filter Water History
You might be interested to know that the very first gravity water filter dates back to 1835 London, England. We know this because it was mentioned in consciouswater with this quote:
“Queen Victoria requested John Doulton (of later to become Royal Doulton), to produce a water filter with his ceramic making capabilities. Using various earth and clay materials, he created the first gravity water filter stoneware, Doulton water filters.”
This actually makes a lot of sense when you think about it because gravity is a very obvious way to filter water.
So there is a good chance that there are earlier examples of people using the gravity process to purify water.
The official history that we can find dates back to London in the 1800s but this is only because we haven’t yet found any earlier instances.
3 Types of Gravity Water Filter Systems
As is the case with all different filter methods, the gravity filter has lots of different variations.
Each type of filter has a different purpose to fulfill so if you’re struggling to know which type of gravity water filter to buy then this list will help!
1. Stainless steel gravity water filters.
This is by far the most popular type of gravity water filter available on the market today and it is probably the one that you are most used to seeing. They are typically big in size and technologically advanced so it’s good for a bigger household or for those who need lots of water. Getting a stainless steel version of the gravity filter is also good if you’re clumsy because it wont break unlike the ceramic version.
2. Ceramic gravity water filters.
As the name suggests, this is a gravity filter that comes in a ceramic shell. This is the perfect choice for people that have allergies. Perhaps you need a natural and healthy way to access your water without worrying about chemicals then you should consider getting a ceramic filter. All you need to do is pour water into the top of the ceramic container and let it work its magic.
3. Gravity water filter bags that you can use for backpacking
This is great if you like hiking, camping or want something to keep for an emergency situation. It can simply be a bag that you tie up a tree and can filter water on the go.
Some of the best things about gravity water filters are how easy it is to use and install.
This is because it’s lighter than other filtration methods and is a good candidate for any situation where you need a portable water filter.
How Effective Is A DIY Gravity Water Filter?
No where near as effective as a regular water filter.
Boiling water is a great way to kill off any final harmful pathogens that are present in your water. However, boiling water can not adequately kill of things like toxic chemicals and neither will it dissolve any contaminated solids.
The only way to guarantee that the water you filter is both safe and bacteria free is to use a professionally made filter.
Professionally made gravity water filter kits usually have a way of indicating that the water is filtered and safe to drink. Also, using a trusted brand like Katadyn or Berkey typically come with a guarantee.
I recommend a gravity filter like the Berkey filter because it’s a trusted brand with professional certification.
Berkey Water Filter Review
The Berkey is by far one of the most popular gravity water filter’s on the market today. Although it is more expensive than the AquaRain it is also of a higher quality.
The Berkey provides very powerful filtration that is capable of removing toxic things like uranium, arsenic, cadmium and lead.
Berkey Water Purifier Complaints
It’s pretty hard to find Berkey water filter problems but if there has to be one then it must be the price. Sadly, all the features, high quality materials and spec means a higher price tag.
Why You Should Get The Big Berkey
The Big Berkey water filter System filters bacteria to a level of 99.99999%
It has powerful proprietary filters that include 9 different types of filtering processes, which means it is able to remove all possible contaminants.
This is a big one for many people: IT REMOVES FLUORIDE! In fact this Berkey has not 1 but 2 fluoride filters.
One of the best things about the Berkey are its filters. For instance, the Black Berkey filters are washable and as if that wasn’t enough you can have their lifetime extended. (Please note that the fluoride filters are not washable).
Despite its size the BK4X2 is also very portable because it’s lightweight. This makes it the ideal outdoor companion for camping or outdoor travels.
It is easy to install straight out of the box and easy to set up without too much expertise.
Made with very high quality stainless steel material.
By far the best thing about the Berkey is its consistency and the guarantee that comes with this brand. Once installed, it will consistently churn out very fresh, clean delicious tasting water. This is irrespective of the water source or even if the water is originally contaminated in any way. I personally use the Big Berkey at my home. It works with all type of water sources.
I’ve even used it to successfully filter all types of water – whether its weird tasting tap water or even swimming pool water!
Choose Professional Solutions like Berkey and AquaTru
Being able to access water that is clean, fresh and contaminant free is necessary for a healthy lifestyle and diet.
Gravity water filters offer a very quick and easy process for purifying contaminated water.
It is so simple that you can make your very own DIY gravity filter at home.
However, if you make it yourself the issue becomes the quality of the water.
Especially because the water filter quality is not guaranteed.
One of the best ways to get around this is to use professionally made gravity water filters in the form of a counter-top water dispenser.
2 of the best models are Berkey and AquaTru.
AquaTru Water Filter | Berkey Water Filter |
- Arsenic: Approx 90% (unspecified). - Fluoride by 91.8% (WITHOUT extra filters). - Lead 97.5% - Benzene 99.9% - Chlorine 96.6% - Cysts 99.99% | - Arsenic by 99.9% (special filters required). - Fluoride by 99.9% (special filters required). - Lead 97.5% - Benzene 99.8% |
Available in 1-size only. | Available in various sizes. |
Plastic materials. | Metal & plastic materials. |
Number of filters: 3 | Number of filters: 2 - 4 |
Filter methods: Mechanical, Reverse Osmosis & Activated Carbon filters. | Filter methods: Black microporous-filters & white fluoride Filters |
4-stage filter process. | 2-stage filter process. |
Holds a maximum water capacity of 3-quarts. | 2.25 Gallons |
45.7 x 45.7 x 38.1 cm | 19" High x 8.5" Diameter |
System: 1 year limited warranty. | Filters: 2 years; System: 1 year. |
Full Performance Data Sheet (AquaTru). | Berkey Contaminants List NSF/ANSI test results |
SPECIAL OFFER? Yes, use code MRWATERGEEK | SPECIAL OFFER? Yes, Big Berkey bundle sale |
Scientific References
WHO (2011) Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality, Fourth Edition. Geneva: World Health Organization.
Ganvir V, Das K. Removal of fluoride from drinking water using aluminum hydroxide coated rice husk ash. J Hazard Mater. 2011; 185: 1287–1294.
McDonagh MS, Whiting PF, Wilson PM, Sutton AJ, Chestnutt I, Cooper J, et al. Systematic review of water fluoridation. BMJ. 2000; 321: 855–859.
Gundry S, Wright J, Conroy R (2004) A systematic review of the health outcomes related to household water quality in developing countries. J Water Health 2: 1–13.
Rosa G, Majorin F, Boisson S, Barstow C, Johnson M, Kirby M, et al. (2014) Assessing the Impact of Water Filters. Improved Cook Stoves on Drinking Water Quality and Household Air Pollution: A Randomised Controlled Trial in Rwanda. PLoS ONE 9(3): e91011. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0091011